Comments
on the 6th PSS Exhibition
The
6th PSS Exhibition was held at
George Street, Edinburgh.
There were 85exhibitors. BJP reported:
This Exhibition presents no
contrast to that of last year, unless it may be in the great
accumulation of cartes de
visite portraits, of which, as might have been anticipated,
some are miserable in the extreme, some possess average merit
and some few would satisfy all the requirements of the most
fastidious taste.
The varieties of process
employed in the production of the pictures are few - indeed year
after year they are getting fewer and fewer.
How much this depends on the system which the Society
adopts of giving medals for the pictures which they consider
best is a matter of opinion.
Referring to the work of John Cramb of Glasgow, BJP
said:
It is evident that
awarding medals for merely pretty and artistic prints is not the
best method of advancing the interests of photography as a
science.
BJP
was disappointed with some of the omissions from the exhibition:
…among the various
contributors to this Exhibition we look in vain for Joubert’s
patent enamel transparencies; photographs in carbon or any other
pigment; specimens
of Ramage’s or any other person’s lithography;
photographic engraving by any of the existing processes,
whether photoglyphs or photogalvonographs. There are no magic lantern slides, nor any of those huge
productions of which the Gallic brethren are celebrated.
It
is a matter of regret that, judging from the scanty attendance
of visitors, the Edinburgh public generally do not seem to be
aware of this collection of pictures in their midst.
6th
PSS Exhibition - Entrants
The
entrants included
-
T Annan
BJP consider his the best
landscape
-
Bedford
-
Claudet
-
Davies
-
Dixon Piper
Perfect photographic manipulation, without however corresponding
taste in the arrangement of subjects
-
Drummond
-
Hering
Some beautiful
portraits
-
Hill and McGlashan
14 portraits - pictures have merit of the highest order
-
Mudd
-
Musgrave
12 fine portraits
-
Orange
-
Robinson
Some of the best frames of cartes de visite
-
Rodger
Some of the best frames of
cartes de visite
-
Tunny
The best group in the room - a family of 12
|