The
British Journal of Photography reported:
"The
exhibition is this year an open one, a separate exhibition for
members having been held in the Autumn. By thus dividing
their activities into two parts, the Hanging Committee have been
enabled to do much greater justice to the works
submitted."
[BJP
1909, p.169]
The
BJP Report gave particular praise to the work of John
Moffat:
"In
Class A (portrait and figure studies) ...Hon. mention is also
made of work by John Moffat ... Mr Moffat's pictures are
both oil prints of great beauty and high technical excellence,
one a portrait of Mr John McWhirter R.A. (No 6) and the other
"Now Waiting Patient the sweet hour of rest", a
charming portrayal of an old lady, absolutely simple and
dignified. It might well have been granted a higher award.
In
addition to these two pictures mentioned, Mr Moffat also shows
in this class a well composed group, "Her First
Lesson".
In
the Landscape section ... ... A very striking
picture is "The Proclamation" by John Moffat (No 63),
a fine and in many ways a great representation of an historic
event. Pictorial representations of such scenes are often
dull and dreary in their ugliness, and of no interest to any but
those who can recognise themselves or their friends in the
crowd, that it is refreshing to find someone who has
subordinated such ideas and dwelt rather on the massing of his
lights and shadows and the giving of dignity to a great historic
event.
There
is no niggling or undue care over details, but a real sense of
breadth and design. This is one of a number of oil prints
in the exhibition, and emphasizes the fact that in the hands of
a good worker it is a process capable of great things."
|